American rhetoric movie speech from the great debaters. The great debaters the quote, we do what we have to do in order to do what we want to do. Jun 18, 2008 the film, loosely based on a true story, revolves around the efforts of debate coach melvin b. The movie inspired me to do my best to be a better speaker, to take time to research my topics and prepare myself before my presentation. No debate for the great debaters the cornell daily sun. The great debaters is a 2007 film about the true story of melvin b. The great debaters is a good case study in all three areas. The great debaters film analysis by jack weiler on prezi.
There was fear of communism in america as it was associated with the soviet union i. Reflection of the movie the great debaters this weekend, i watch a very nice movie called the great debaters. This team made up of one girl, samantha booke, and three young men, james farmer jr. What does james say to henry later that upsets henry, why. Though the great debaters produced by oprah winfrey is filled with hope and inspiration, it is marred by historical inaccuracies and a marked imbalance in its racial portrayals. The argument that samantha booke gave at debate team tryouts. Why does samantha booke want to join the debate team. The great debaters is a 2007 american biographical drama film directed by and starring denzel washington. Another character on the team, samantha booke, is based on the real individual. Greg wroblewski the great debaters is a fictionalized treatment of the superlative debate teams coached by melvin tolson at wiley college in the 1930s.
The great debaters politics and film database longwood blogs. This theme is paramount in denzel washingtons movie, the great debaters. We learn of samantha booke jurnee smollett, a composite character based mostly on the real henrietta bell, one of the first women members of the wiley college team and. Samantha booke, henry lowe and hamilton burgess were the members of this great team of debaters. The great debaters script fast gospel man my soul is a witness soul is a witness my soul is a witness yeah, yeah soul is a witness oh, yeah before l go oh before l go fore l go before l go, soul is a witness speaker heavenly father, we come before thee, knee bent and body bowed in the humblest way that we know how. The great debaters is one of the great movies of 2007. The great debaters is een amerikaanse film uit 2007 geregisseerd. Tolson jurnee smollet based on the individua henrietta bell wells aspiring lawyer only woman on the debate team displays confidence 1930s marshall, texas wiley college height of the great depression 1935. At that time, government still mired the law which was created since 1870s to develop the implementation of apartheid or racial discrimination. Henry lowe body henry nate parker is introduced hitting on a young lady at a party.
She said she was gratified that we did her character justice, the young star recalled. The great debaters question guide henry county schools. Julia pittman psyc 0501 reflection of the great debaters before beginning the great debaters directed by denzel washington in 2007, i had thought it was a documentary about a very good debate team. This essay argues that the great debaters is a text that is not simply a story about wiley colleges debate triumphs during the 1930s, but that the film shares a temporal bond to the time in which it was released in. A brilliant young woman i know was asked once to support her argument in favor of social welfare. Henrietta bell wells samantha booke s character in the film is based on ms. Tolson makes the selection of the main characters to be on the debate team, henry lowe and hamilton burgess are the primary debaters with samantha booke and james farmer jr.
The great debaters marred by inaccuracies, imbalance. The great debaters movie is so educational that watching it made me feel like i have been in a classroom session. Learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools. The entire town has become so inspired by the development of the young debaters, to the point of rebelling when tolson is imprisoned, and winning his freedom from jail. Instead, the great debaters has scenes of people talking about ideas within what boils down to a standard, formula sports movie. Quotes will be submitted for approval by the rt staff. Her role as the feisty and loquacious samantha booke is truly inspired. In the movie the great debaters, is the character of. Jan 05, 2008 henrietta wells was a real woman and the first on the wiley debate team. That is the question which begs to be answered in the course of appraising the great debaters, an inspirational biopic about a professor who, in 1935, allegedly forged the fledgling debate team at a tiny black college into a nationallyranked powerhouse that took on harvard university in a big showdown aired on radio live all across the country.
The great debaters shows how the black realized that education was the key to their success. In addition to tolson, henry lowe nate parker is based on henry heights, who, according to teammate henrietta bell upon whom the character of samantha brooke, played by. And parker and whitaker expressed the hope that if the figures they were playing could have lived to see. Wiley was a tiny allblack college in a small texas town. Smollett is pleased at the reaction that she is receiving for her efforts.
Tolson, a professor at wiley college in texas who, in 1935, inspired students to form the schools first debate team, which went on to challenge harvard in the national championship. Henry lowe jurnee smollett samantha booke denzel whitaker james farmer jr. The great debaters are based on a true story about an all black debate team journey to the top. You know, we are products of samantha brooke and thats. The great debaters script transcript from the screenplay. The great debaters marred by inaccuracies, imbalance movie. Although debate teacher melvin tolson is a stock character from washingtons repertoire a firebrand given to rousing speeches and a stoical sense of righteousness its also a typically strong performance.
Kinyon great debaters essay 6 march 20 the great debaters based on a true story, the movie the great debaters is about a four person debate team at the historically black, wiley college in marshall, tx. An enlightened struggle against racial oppression during the depression by helen halyard february 2008 directed by denzel washington, written by robert eisele, produced by. Study 40 terms the great debaters flashcards quizlet. Henry heights henry lowe s character in the film is based on mr. Tolson, a professor at wiley college in texas who, in 1935, inspired students to form the schools first debate team, which went on to challenge harvard in the national championship directed by denzel washington. The great debaters is about an underdog debate team that wins a national championship, and some critics have complained that it follows the formula of all sports movies by leading up, through great adversity, to a victory at the end. Henry lowe, what is the only place other than school where one can. The 2007 film the great debaters shows viewers the triumphant rise of the. The team and the coach react with a sick, helpless fear, and henry lowe, the. Inspirational great debaters has its pros and cons movies. Dec 25, 2007 the great debaters synopsis the story of professor melvin b. Farmer, jamess father, is the first africanamerican who manages to get a doctorate degree in texas. Its almost impossible for men to know what women want, or, more important, why they want what they want because of the complete differences between their bodies and hormones.
Beyond his academic duties, tolson was an accomplished poet, journalist and social activist. There are enough things to admire about the great debaters, the heavily fictionalized true story of the little debate team that could, that your impulse is. In her first debate attempt, samantha booke cites one of president franklin. The great debaters final debate bedford public schools. The great debaters cast on mentoring future leaders. The great debaters is a 2007 american biographical drama film directed by and starring.
Who are some of the people referenced in the debate. Over time they all white debate teams that are prejudice of the black students. The lot makes a definite approach to their speech making, driven by logos, pathos and ethos. Stephen holden they changed the debate topics to always. The character in the film is based on the actual person, james farmer, jr. He very much wants his son to follow his path and urges him to study hard.
A quote can be a single line from one character or a memorable dialog between several characters. Second point it pulls you in and relates to the harsh history. Feb 01, 2008 the great debaters is a magnificent movie. It is based off of the debate team of wiley college, a small religious black school in east texas, during the great depression in the 1930s. Henrietta wells, who are represented as henry lowe and samantha booke in the movie. Jurnee smollett as samantha booke jermaine williams as. According to the professor, what type of sport is debate.
Heres a movie about ideas thats a bit too timid to actually be about them. Nate parker henry lowe, jurnee smollett samantha booke, denzel. Travel plays both a symbolic and tangible role in the film as the team. The great debaters starts, like many films, in transition. The performances, or the cinematography, historical care, or directorship all lift it out of the ordinary. She was one of the two debaters in the historic debate depicted in the film. The latter shows promise but needs polishing, and tolson thinks he can provide that. And the fact that as a female character, its rare that i get to go act on a role. Dec 24, 2007 the great debaters is about an underdog debate team that wins a national championship, and some critics have complained that it follows the formula of all sports movies by leading up, through great adversity, to a victory at the end. And parker and whitaker expressed the hope that if the figures they were playing could have lived to see the great debaters, theyd feel the same way. It is based on an article written about the wiley college debate team by tony scherman for the spring 1997 issue of american legacy the film costars forest whitaker, denzel washington, kimberly elise, nate parker, gina ravera, jermaine williams and jurnee smollett. The great debaters 2007 nate parker as henry lowe imdb. The great debaters offers a fictionalized and limited account of the exploits of the awardwinning wiley college debate team headed by melvin b.
One example of this racial divide in the great debaters is a scene when james farmer sr. Talented, likes to talk, was on the team the previous year. The great debaters 2007 by johnny web uncle scoopy. The great debaters cast and crew cast photos and info. Sep 15, 2014 this weekend, i watch a very nice movie called the great debaters. So, you know, henry lowe, he is a womanizer, but hes a womanizer for a reason. For smolletts character, samantha brooke, its about never quitting. There are enough things to admire about the great debaters, the heavily. Thats why smollett took such pride in henrietta bells reaction to the film. Though, like many of the characters in this film, brooke is a composite of real and imagined, wells and her participation in the great debaters is all too real. Tolson, lead his debate team to such high success in a time and place where black success was so heavily denied inspired my own academic success.
Henry, samantha, hamilton, james, and their professor, mr. A narrative analysis of the film the great debaters and its. The great debaters summary essay example studymoose. If you think im going to criticize an oprah movie, youre crazy. Jermaine williams hamilton burgess gina ravera ruth tolson john heard sheriff dozier kimberly elise pearl farmer devyn tyler helen farmer trenton mcclain boyd nathanial farmer ritchie montgomery deputy jackson walker pig owner tim parati pig farmer robert x. Parker as henry lowe is sort of the leader of the debaters yet plays a surprisingly small role in the showdown in harvard. It puts everything in context and builds to a crescendo. The great debaters is based on the true story of the wiley college. In the 2disc edition, the first disc includes no extra material, but the second disc includes an audio commentary, a making of documentary, deleted scenes, featurettes, and a still gallery. How many sports movies, or movies about underdogs competing in any way, have you seen that end in.
The great debaters, directed by denzel washington, is an inspirational movie about a specific debate team overcoming racism in the segregated south. Tolson denzel washington at historically black wiley college to place his team on equal footing with whites in the american south during the 1930s, when jim crow laws were common and lynch mobs were a pervasive fear for blacks. The great debaters julia pittman psyc 0501 reflection. Make a list of four convictions strong beliefs that guide your actions and words that you have in your life. Samantha booke jurnee smollett, henry lowe nate parker and hamilton. The two white pig farmers who owned the pig confront him about it.
When farmer says he doesnt have that much, one of the farmers pulls a gun. Never would i have thought it was about racial segregation, education, and civil rights. Washingtons character and mentoring encouraged the young actors he worked. It is the active refusal to obey certain laws, demands, and commands of a government, or of an occupying international power. The great debaters question guide henry county school. He offers her a drink from his own personal flask and leans in to kiss her.
The great debaters by denzel washington, forest whitaker. I will do the reflection and recommend this movie to you. Denzel washington impresses both in front of the camera and behind it in the great debaters, his second feature as a director. At that time, government still mired the law which was created since 1870s to develop the implementation of. Tolson, an africanamerican english professor, during the depression years.
Her onscreen grace and beauty coupled with her ability to hold audiences captive are pretty astounding. The great debaters is oprahproduced, oprahapproved, and oprahendorsed. Discover what genre great debaters, the, 2007, directed by denzel washington, with denzel washington, forest whitaker, kimberly elise, belongs at turner classic movies. Nevertheless, tolson sets out to motivate his students, choosing james jr. The great debaters was a very powerful and inspirational movie. A narrative analysis of the film the great debaters and.
Inspirational great debaters has its pros and cons. Smollett as samantha booke is chosen the first woman to ever debate and n. We learn of samantha booke jurnee smollett, a composite character based mostly on the real henrietta bell, one of the. Although it is fictionalized, the characters are based on real people. Tolson who formed a debate team at an african american college in the 1930s. Overall this movie is a masterpiece of the drama genre and definitely a milestone of denzel washington as director. Inspired by the critically acclaimed hollywood film the great debaters, the real great debaters of wiley college unveils the true story of wiley college s 1935 debate team and their groundbreaking defeat of the allwhite reigning national championship debate team at the university of southern california. The film, loosely based on a true story, revolves around the efforts of debate coach melvin b. The movie orbited around the lives of 5 characters who attended wiley college in texas.
Dec 25, 2007 there are enough things to admire about the great debaters, the heavily fictionalized true story of the little debate team that could, that your impulse is to forgive the movie its shortcomings. It is the mid1930s and professor tolson assembles a. For example, the samantha booke character is based loosely on henrietta bell wells, who was on the 1930 wiley debate team and became a social worker, not a lawyer as the movie. Next, choose a character you identify with most from the film. It makes you feel and relate to the people in the film. The characters reactions to these events, it implies, sow the seeds of the. It reminds us of what it means to be excellent, to stand for something good, to love with all our hearts, and to shine. Which argument does henry lowe use to win the first debate. Before this film was produced, very little was generally known about wiley, a.
The great debaters 2007 the great debaters 2007 user. Its a perfectly respectable drama, made from the inspiring sports movie template but centered around a college debate team instead of a sports team. Study 20 terms the great debaters flashcards quizlet. In the movie the great debaters, is the character of henry. How many sports movies, or movies about underdogs competing in any way, have you seen that end in defeat. Reflection of the movie the great debaters charless blog.
Apr 24, 2015 the great debaters was a movie that took place during the great depression, in a time where racism and discrimination against blacks was thriving. Samantha booke takes the bus to school and is watching her impoverished. This movie tell a story that happened in 1930s in texas. Schools the only place you can read all day, except prison. Using a perspective developed from paul ricouers time and. Told with the againstallodds mentality reserved for most underdog tales, denzel washingtons the great debaters inspired by a true story recounts how a plucky debate team from allblack wiley college systematically defeated anyone who dared oppose them until they earned an impossible title shot against the scholars of harvard university.
214 189 272 1095 221 1234 627 12 707 1094 1137 914 456 330 598 604 131 297 1160 276 275 61 1310 306 892 1529 460 1535 250 491 279 1009 351 390 610 812 695 45 137